Ashanti vs Alicia Keys: Who Wore It Best?

I really LOVE this green Stella McCartney dress. But with a hefty price tag of over $3,000 our love affair must cool down until this number goes on sale! The cut & color looks brilliant on both Alicia and Ashanti but there's something I'm not feeling with version, perhaps its her black leather jacket? Hmmmm..it's a battle of the singers! Who rocked this look best? Ashanti or Alicia?